Top 10 Life Insurance Companies in the US for Great Customer Service (Based on 2025 Reviews and Ratings)

Life insurance is key to protecting your family. But good customer service matters just as much as the policy itself. In 2025, with rising costs and more online tools, people want insurers that are easy to reach, quick to help, and clear in their answers. This article looks at the top 10 life insurance companies in the US, ranked by customer service. We used data from J.D. Power's 2024 U.S. Individual Life Insurance Study (the latest full report as of October 2025), plus reviews from Bankrate, Forbes, NerdWallet, and customer sites like Trustpilot and ConsumerAffairs. These rankings focus on satisfaction scores, complaint rates, and real user feedback.

We ranked them based on overall customer happiness, ease of contact, claim handling, and digital tools. Note: Prudential Financial, a big name in the industry, ranks lower due to mixed reviews on wait times and support. Let's dive in.

1. State Farm

State Farm tops the list for the fifth year in a row in J.D. Power's study, with a score of 699 out of 800. Customers love the friendly local agents and fast claims—over 80% say they get help within a day. In the 2025 Bankrate Awards, it won Best Term Life Insurer for its simple app and 24/7 phone line. Users on Trustpilot give it 4.2 stars, praising quick policy changes. If you want a personal touch, this is it.

2. Guardian Life

Guardian ranks second in J.D. Power (685 points), shining in communication and product advice. NerdWallet calls it a top pick for whole life policies, with 77% of customers happy with email support. Recent 2025 reviews highlight low complaint rates (NAIC index of 0.45) and free weekend calls. Forbes notes its strong digital portal for tracking claims. Great for families needing long-term help.

3. MassMutual

Third in J.D. Power (673 points), MassMutual wins for trust and easy online tools. U.S. News ranks it #1 overall in 2025 for customer service surveys, with 85% of users rating interactions as "excellent." It offers no-exam options up to $3 million, and Bankrate praises its 6.4% dividend rate for 2025. Customer stories on ConsumerAffairs (4.1 stars) focus on helpful advisors during tough times.

4. Northwestern Mutual

Known for financial planning, it scores high (around 800 in past J.D. Power segments) for personalized service. Insurance.com's 2025 survey gives it 4.5 stars, with a 91% trust rate. Users like the app for real-time updates, and it's top for the whole life in CNBC Select. Low NAIC complaints (0.32) mean fewer headaches. Ideal if you want advice beyond just insurance.

5. USAA

USAA leads for military families, ranking high in J.D. Power annuity studies (extended to life in 2025 reviews). Money.com gives it 4.8 stars for quick claims (under 20 days average). It's not open to all, but members rave about 24/7 chat and no-fee policies on Yelp (4.3 stars). 2025 news highlights its A++ AM Best rating for reliability.

6. Nationwide

Nationwide ties for third in some J.D. Power factors, with strong digital scores (730 in the 2025 Insurance Digital Study). Insurify ranks it top for term life service, with 82% satisfaction in ease of business. Users love the free living benefits riders and the mobile app. The Forbes 2025 list notes a few complaints (NAIC 0.41) and fast payouts.

7. Amica

Amica excels in overall satisfaction, ranking high in J.D. Power's 2025 digital experience (724 points). NerdWallet picks it for customizable policies and live chat support. Customer reviews on Trustpilot (4.4 stars) praise weekend hours and clear emails. It's great for high-value homes with life add-ons, per Business Insider.

8. Penn Mutual

A mutual company, Penn Mutual, scores well in Insurance & Estates' 2025 rankings for non-captive agents and A+ financials. J.D. Power gives it solid marks for product advice. Users report 90% renewal rates on Insure.com, with easy conversions from term to whole life. Low costs and helpful calls make it a quiet winner.

9. New York Life

With 180 years in business, it ranks in Forbes' 2025 Most Admired list. J.D. Power scores it above average for interaction (790+). Bankrate notes its strong whole life dividends and agent network. Reviews on ConsumerAffairs (3.9 stars) highlight reliable claims, though some want better apps. Solid for lifelong coverage.

10. Protective

Protective rounds out the top 10 with competitive rates and good service scores in U.S. News 2025. It ties for best no-exam in Bankrate Awards, with 78% customer satisfaction. The NAIC index is low (0.38), and users like the quick underwriting. Forbes praises its term policies, but watch for rider fees.

Where Does Prudential Fit In?

Prudential offers solid policies like term and universal life, with an A+ AM Best rating for financial strength. But customer service lags. In J.D. Power's 2024 study, it scored below average at 626 points, ranking near the bottom of 21 companies. Reviews on Trustpilot (1.2 stars from 126 users) and ConsumerAffairs complain about long hold times, hard-to-reach agents, and claim delays—some wait weeks for simple updates. Its NAIC complaint index is 0.66, higher than peers, meaning more issues per policy. In Insure.com's 2025 survey, only 77% were happy with the service, and it didn't crack top lists from Bankrate or Forbes. Recent news focuses on its sustainability report, not service wins. If you pick Prudential, use an agent for better support.

Quick Comparison Table Image

In 2025, customer service can make or break your peace of mind. These top 10 stand out for making life insurance feel simple, not stressful. Always talk to an advisor for your fit.

Read about: Top 10 Prudential Life Insurance Company in the US and their New Offers in 2025